Choosing the wrong contractor is the single most common source of renovation disasters in London. Here is a systematic approach to contractor selection that reduces the risk significantly.
Contractor selection is the highest-stakes decision in a renovation project. The quality of the contractor determines not just the quality of the finished work, but the experience of the process — whether the programme is managed, communication is clear, problems are resolved without drama, and costs stay close to the agreed figure. A poor contractor choice is expensive and stressful to recover from; in the worst cases, it results in unfinished work and legal proceedings.
This guide sets out a systematic approach to contractor selection for London renovation projects.
Start with referrals, not Google
The most reliable source of a good contractor is a personal referral from someone who has had a similar project completed to a standard comparable to what you want. Architects and interior designers are often the best source — they work with multiple contractors and have direct knowledge of who performs well on projects of a particular type and scale.
Ask specifically: would you use this contractor again? How did they handle problems when they arose (because they always do)? Did the final cost match the tender price? Was the programme broadly adhered to?
A contractor who produces beautiful Instagram photos but is not recommended by anyone who has worked with them is a risk.
What to look for in a contractor
Track record on comparable projects: A contractor experienced in bathroom refurbishment is not necessarily qualified to run a whole-house renovation involving structural works, basement waterproofing, and specialist stone installation. Ask for examples of projects similar in scope and value to yours. Visit a completed project if possible.
Direct employment versus subcontracting: The best contractors have key tradespeople directly employed — carpenters, painters, plasterers — and use specialist subcontractors (electricians, plumbers) from an established network they have worked with repeatedly. A contractor who subcontracts everything with no direct workforce has limited control over quality and programme.
Financial stability: A contractor who is financially marginal will accept jobs they cannot properly resource, front-load cash flow by over-claiming on interim payments, and in the worst case, dissolve partway through the project. Request two or three trade references (not client references) — suppliers who can confirm the contractor pays on time. Consider a credit check for large projects.
Site management: Who will be on site day-to-day? For a project of any complexity, a dedicated site manager or foreman is essential. If the proprietor of the business is personally running every project, their attention will be divided. Ask to meet the person who will actually run your project, not just the person presenting for the tender.
Insurance: Contractors must have public liability insurance (minimum £2m for most domestic projects) and employers' liability insurance. Request certificates before work begins. Do not accept assurances — only certificates.
The tender process
Obtain at least three tender prices for any project above £50,000. For larger projects (£200,000+), a formal tender with a detailed bill of quantities prepared by a quantity surveyor gives you comparability between tenders.
A useful test: if one tender is significantly lower than the other two, ask the low tenderer to explain the difference. Either they have missed scope (a risk), they are buying the work at an unsustainable price (a risk), or they have found a genuine efficiency. A contractor who cannot explain the difference confidently is a risk to appoint.
Conversely, a tender that is significantly higher than the others warrants the same scrutiny. A premium price is not inherently evidence of premium quality.
Contract
Always use a written contract. The JCT Minor Works Building Contract is suitable for most domestic renovation projects. Key contract provisions to confirm:
- —Scope of works: Exactly what is included, and what is explicitly excluded
- —Contract sum: The agreed price and how variations will be valued
- —Programme: Start date, completion date, and any key milestones
- —Payment terms: Interim payment schedule (typically monthly valuations), retention provisions
- —Dispute resolution: Adjudication under the Scheme for Construction Contracts
Avoid starting work on the basis of a letter of intent or verbal agreement for any project above £20,000. If a contractor will not sign a standard contract form, that is diagnostic information.
Red flags to walk away from
- —Requests for large cash payments upfront (more than 10–15% for a mobilisation payment is unusual)
- —Reluctance to provide a written programme
- —Cannot provide references for comparable recent projects
- —No fixed business address, limited online presence, and unwillingness to be identified formally
- —Pressure to start immediately without a signed contract
- —Dramatic underbidding versus comparable tenders
- —Subcontracts everything with no directly employed workforce
- —Has recently changed company name (search Companies House for the principals)
During the project
Once appointed, the best contractor relationships are maintained by:
- —Clear, written communication for any changes to scope
- —Timely payment of agreed interim valuations (cash flow problems cascade quickly)
- —A single point of contact on the client side — multiple clients giving instructions creates confusion and is a driver of variation cost
- —Weekly site meetings with written minutes
ASAAN operates as a main contractor on whole-property London renovation projects, providing a dedicated site manager, detailed programme, and monthly cost reporting on every project. If you are in the contractor selection process for a project of this type, we would be pleased to discuss our approach.
Discuss Your Project
Ready to get started?
Our team is happy to visit your property and talk through what's involved.